Little j is a waste a of time. Soft dude, who thinks he’s a tough Philly guy. Weak jokes, silly lines that his employee’s on the show have to roll with.

Bob Kelly is not funny, ruins bits, ruins the flow and just generally ruins the bonfire. As a human being I don’t like him but I put up with him for as long as I could. His delusions have gotten old, plus the dude just lies. Poop knife for your over 10 year old kid? Somebody check this dudes hard drives cause that is some sus stuff.

Your love for a broken puppet is wonderful I can’t wait to hear the recap

😂🤣😅😂

Bobby’s takes are that of a 75 year old. This show is getting older by the day…

I always thought that impersonation isn’t really comedy. Now Dan Soder just impersonates Shane Gillis - even has the website - kinda weasel vibe

Based on other reviews, it seems like I’m supposed to roast the hosts while giving them 5 stars…however, I will not. Although it WAS better with Dan, Bobby brings a certain “old guy” aspect to the show. I absolutely adore and despise Jacob, (as everyone should)… black Lou and Christine are phenomenal background characters. Everyone has the ability to be so unlikeable … and yet so charming and blunt. Jay is an absolute honest GEM! (that comedy, AND THE WORLD, needs more of). I sincerely hope that they read these reviews because as an old school fan of the show… I think they’d appreciate this. Crackle crackle @djbartjenkins 😚

Replace Bobby with Derosa and the show would be enjoyable again

Words

Is such a fat idiot.

He need to shut his mouth.

Comments are gay

Would be 5 stars without that lump Bobby

Between the fatness and smokers ashtray of a voice…hearing Jay just spew absolute filth makes me physically recoil. He’s like edgy 13 year old. Bobby is just terrible.

Replace Bobby with anyone or anything else. Dawkins would be an improvement.

Love this Show and its podcast portion. It’s always a pleasure listening and finds a way to make me smile. Speaking of the show. Why can’t Bobby pronounce Donnell correct? Does our Boston buddy have trouble letting go of them hard R’s 🤣

Only ever talks about weird pedo stuff or gay porn. Bobby’s not Dan. Just end it.

This show used to be 5 stars. Then Soder left and we are stuck with Bobby Kelly. I’m shocked Kelly has made a living as a comedian because he can’t tell a funny joke and steps all over everyone else’s jokes. This whole podcast is now unfunny jokes and porn. Every episode is porn. They used to talk about documentaries, movies, music. Anything and everything. Now it’s just porn

Been a loooong time listener but had to write a review after pulling up a portable chair around the fire and listening to this episode! You guys are amazing and Dan’s farts don’t smell. #cracklecrackle Love you, Jeans! 👖 🔥

The pod is a staple of my morning routine. The whole crew is the best there is

Constantly watching videos we can’t see if we are just listening to the podcast like I’d assume most people are makes for a terrible show. We CANT see what you guys are looking at?! This was never the format before.

^ For brevity, title says it all. Bye

OK

One of my favorite guests or family

For a room of straight men, they spent WAY too much time discussing other men’s organs

Bobby Kelly kills every jay joke that follow up is horrible. It’s what we miss bout soder. Disappointing

Show was funnier with Soder. Hard to believe how much of a gullible maga meathead Bobby is.

Bring back soder!

I never thought I’d stop listening but Bobby is extremely unfunny. Maybe if you get a new co host next year I’ll listen again.

Pretty much unlistenable they should really think about the people that are trying to listen and not just listening to themselves talk.

Was great with Dan Soder, even better with Robert Kelly

At first I thought it was funny that Dan's picture was still up and Bobby’s wasn’t. Now it’s getting sad yet even funnier. I assume he doesn’t know. Oh yeah, the show is great. I’ve listened daily for years.

To many commercials/ad reads. Always was worth the wait for the show but now it isn’t worth it. Enjoy as revenue folks. It’s gonna put the show into the ground.

Big Jay is the best of the best. Love every day I get to hear him riff.

Bobby Kelly is not a funny person please get a someone more qualified to replace him lord have mercy on my soul this guy is a total drop off from Dan soder I love Jay and the rest of crew but Robert Kelly is terrible

Bobby absolutely ruined this show.

On the episode for Halloween 2023, since Jane wasn’t in town, they simply replayed an old episode, rather than letting Bobby host with another guest host. No one watched the show on Monday when they found out Big J wasn’t on air. Then, on Tuesday, they had the common sense to run a previously aired episode, rather than a live episode without Jay.

These guys are buttholes. Just buttholes.

It’s been amazing having the opportunity to listen to Big Jay, one of my all time favorite comics, everyday for years now… but I can’t any longer at the cost of Bobby Kelly.

It’s getting worse

Stop the Bobby Kelly hate. He’s 1000% funnier than anyone trashing him; he’s nothing like Schaub. Who also gets far too much hate, but that’s for TFAK, and also I wonder how many people would speak to him like that in person? Bobby, they’d be lucky to hold your jock. Don’t ever change. *insert skanks chant* BOB-BY BOB-BY, PS I love that Jacob got his jacket

Never stop.

Ham Party

Please stop swallowing on mic Please bring soder back it’s just not the same You can hear it in jays voice in basic convo how soder brings out that boyish feeling in jay Yo, can you please stop uploading old episodes to serious and acting like the brand new

Subscribed to Sirius for this show, alone. Big Jay is great, Bobby is really good, and Christine, Jacob, DJ Lou, and Black Lou make the show one of my favorites.

When is the name of the show changing to “Unmask of Bobby Kelly”? Need a third mic or new cohost

Snake Pit!!

It’s getting better, but not nearly as funny as the old show and I no longer anticipate new episodes.

Jay and not Dan are so fun. I love Dan, but not Dan is awesome.

The show is kinda funny but Bobby Kelly’s clicking sounds on the last episode drove me up the wall. I have it a shot after Dan left but had to unfollow.