Love the Harry Potter theories!! I got a quiz question for you : how many people gave harry sweets when he took down Quirrell. Extra points if you can name all of them that are told!:)

If you agree, repost anywhere and add your name 1. Ravenpuff Kitten 2.

I love this podcast, but I think y’all could cover a lot more topics. Like maybe lord of the rings. If you haven’t read it it’s ok I only read it by 3RD GRADE.

Hey brother! Love you guys’ content, it’s never boring. I just have one suggestion/request: please give me more Pixar and Marvel theories! But seriously, you guys are responsible for getting me back into Harry Potter and reread the books, I can’t thank you enough. See you in another life brothers, KingXhosa616 (P.S. Do you get the Marvel references in my name?)

LOVE U GUYS PLEASE KEEP DOING HARRY POTTER CONTENT

Heyyyyyy Brother! Love the podcast! Can’t get enough! Love diving deeper into my favorite world and you guys are the funnest! Keep up the great work! My question is what if Lily did step aside and let Voldemort kill Harry? Knowing her character she definitely wouldn’t, but if she had, what would happen with the sacrificial love? Lily raising Harry? Voldemort’s fall and rise? Love to hear your thoughts!

I’ve been listening to this show for so long, and I just love it! I first discovered it thought the what if Harry was in Slytherin, and I’ve been stuck on it ever since! However, I’ve always wondered what you have happened if Barty Crouch had never escaped Azkaban. Would the Ministry ever go after Harry? Would Voldemort return? I have so many questions about that…

Please do a What if Hermione was in Ravenclaw.

Can you do a why did Luna lovegood google autofill please! Thanks😁

I love love love ur hp. Content pls do what if hermione was in raven law

This is a great podcast and I love listening to J & Ben while doing just about anything! I really like your theorys. You guys are awesome!

Would a un breakable vow kill Voldemort with horcuxes? Like would the charm kill all of the soul parts? Or would he just turn to mist? Love the show!

Yay! Non Harry Potter content!!!

What if the thematic three (Harry, Ron, herminy) were in Ravenclaw?

I’ve been listening for a while and I love HP. You would be surprised how much you guys are in my ears :).I have some suggestions; What if Sirius was at the ministry? And What if Kreatur didn't come back from the lake?Anyway I love the podcast and I love to listen to it when I’m doing random tasks and stuff like that. 5 stars!!⭐️

I love this podcast!!! It’s amazing!!! 🤩 So, I have a question, what if Cedric didn’t die and came back to hogwarts with Harry? Thanks! P.S. Can you pleaseeeeeeeeeeeee read Keeper of the Lost Cities and do an episode on it? Pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

For a long time, I just watched on YouTube. The podcast version is just so much better for me though! I’m still in school, so this is good for homework background noise. Side Note: Anyone else need some sound but not too much sound to do like anything? I also use this podcast as I clean, or when I shower. I just love the theories and all the other stuff on your channel, and I can recognize both of the voices without even having to see you guys. This is so perfect and I love the pair of you! Question I just can’t get over: If Voldemort killed so many people, why does he only have 7 horcruxes? That makes me assume there must be some sort of spell to make one. He didn’t have time when Harry was casted to make him one. Must be before so Harry can be one. Ok so here is the actual idea about this: After Voldemort killed James, he knew he was going to give Lily the choice, and he must have thought (really my mind thought for Voldemort) “I’m lord Voldemort and I am going to offer her the chance to live, and I don’t think she will choose death because I can’t understand love and death is my greatest fear, so I am just going to cast the spell now for Harry’s Death” meet the real truth. About your latest video: If Hagrid had it in the open, and Peter took it, wouldn’t Hagrid notice? And if he noticed, wouldn’t he tell Dumbledore?

Y’all should do a scathing review on umbridge

I love this podcast so much!! You guys are AWESOME hp ⚡️theorists. I am thinking about starting my own Harry Potter/Magical Creatures podcast (not trying to steal your thunder 🫣😅) and was hoping you could give me some words of advice? If so I’d be great if you guys could give me a shout out in your next episode maybe? If so, Be on the look out for a new hp pod 2025 😁Byeee! Thank you 🙏 May the force be with you!!! 🌟🗡️🚀👾

Heyyyyyy Brotherrrrr! I love listening to all the cool and interesting theories! I also love your other podcast Through The Griffin Door! One question…..How do muggleborns like Hermione get wizarding money????🧐 Thank you! 😁

i love them but why did they stop doing star wars theories

Long time listener both podcasts and on YouTube. I often listen at work and you make my day with your podcasts. Now I do have a Question. Do you think Hagrid only acts simple? We seen him give the Trio information (I shouldn’t have said that) only when they really need the information. It also possible he gave Qurill the information to get past Fluffy only after he got the go ahead from Dumbledore. Even letting the Trio get the blame for norbert could be seen as a calculated Slytherin type of behavior. My theory is that Hagrid is not as simple as he seems and only pretends to act as a simple minded Half Giant so others would underestimate him.

I love Harry Potter and they make so many cool fan theories! I have been watching them on YouTube for 2 years and I just found out that they have a podcast with their YouTube videos on it and it’s amazing

This is my current favorite podcast and I try to listen to every new episode and love watching and listening to them and it makes my day when they upload

I LOVE Super Carlin Brothers and have for a long time now! I’m a giant Potterhead and it’s great to listen to all your guys’ theories and explainers. My phone is so old it can’t run the YouTube app anymore, so the podcast version is great! Thanks for reading my review on Through the Griffin Door, and I’ll see you on the DC leg of (Through the Griffin) tour! - NerdyNerd29 P.S. I think ReadingPerson1’s idea was great. What if Hermione was in Ravenclaw?

Such a great podcast and YouTube channel! Can you do A Series Of Unfortunate Events, a TON more MCU and a lot more Star Wars? Thanks 🙏!

I love this podcast, so much HP and Pixar. But could you please contenue if nevil was the chosen one, and maybe if you could do more MARVEL and Star Wars stuff also I would think it awsome if you could do more sorting marvel characters into HP houses. Thanks!!!😀😀😀 PS you should do some lord of the rings stuff. Also is there any pointers to creating a podcast, im trying to make one. Ps ps the one and only rizzler has the right idea

This podcast is like, 👌🏾, chefs kiss. As a Slytherin, I love seeing how Harry would have been in Slytherin. This podcast version is great for when I do homework or when I have to clean my room, or just background noise for when I’m in the car or drawing. The dad jokes just tie it all together. Like the jokes are so bad that I have to laugh, it’s way too good. Slay🥴🥴🥴 also the shots at Snape are crrrrraaaaazzzy. But did you have to make Freddy die😭😭😭 also pikanator137’s idea is great!

This podcast is amazing I not allowed to watch YouTube so this lets me hear my friends favorite YouTube channel and now mine

Very good ⚡️⚡️⚡️

I Iove super Carlin brothers ❤️❤️❤️👍🏻👍🏻💕💕🥳🥳

I love your show so much, but I use it to fall asleep and the intro music is really loud, so can you please make the intro music just a little quieter. THANK YOU 😄😄😄 P.s Can you do more long form Harry Potter episodes. And Harry Potter google auto fill

You can always count on jay and Ben to answer every Disney question! They always know the perfect Disney theory!

It’s fun to listen to with hundreds of theories and they’re really interesting. If you are a nerd then this is the perfect thing for you to listen to. I’ve been listening to it for a year and a half and it’s amazing and sososo interesting. And there is so much HP theories which I love, thank ya’ll for doing this!

Can you PLEASE add more Pixar Cars? Thank you!

I love your HP content and your Pixar content. Been listening to you for 2 years now and I still love you guys. One recommendation is to continue what if Neville was the chosen one series. I know it takes a long time to make and your really busy with your kids and life. But it would make my day if you guys continued it😀! P.S if you like this podcast you should listen to the popcorn culture. Ben and Jay talk about their life and other fun stuff.

Awesome Harry a potter content! (Yes that’s all I care about.) 😃😃😄😄😄

Can you do anything other than harry potter, hunger games and star wars. Please try something new. I think you would enjoy percy jackson and the olympians or the owl house(a recently completed Disney series). So please try something new. But overall the podcast is great :) If you are looking for a cool new book series I would recommend keeper of the lost cities.

Wish you would add more Star Wars podcasts

I’ve just wanted to say thank you so much for entertaining me for the past 6 years that I’ve been a fan. I love your Pixar theories and you two are like friends to me! Thanks again for all these years of fun content! 🤩🤩🤩

The Super Carlin Brothers podcast has theories, what ifs, quizzes, and just recently dive ins for Harry Potter. They are very funny and very detailed, and have a lot of questions that some fans haven’t considered. I love all of their theories and personal conversations that they have in between the actual episode. Now I know only a good review doesn’t help decide so I will say if you don’t like side convos, blurry audio, or constant rambling than you may not enjoy this podcast. Fortunately for me though, I love all of those things and I love this podcast. Thank you Super Carlin Brother for your craft with us and making me laugh.

So. As a thirteen year old girl who started listening to this podcast/channel for its Harry Potter content only a year and a half ago, I have gotten in to all of the fandoms and almost listened to all of the 401 episodes! I am absolutely obsessed and I hope to meet them someday.

Love the HP content marvel content and the whole Pixar theory

It’s great. Makes time fly by

Keep up the good work bro try to tone it down a bit in the Harry Potter department I would like more Pixar theory and Disney and how the heck have you not read Percy Jackson?!! I just got a phone like a month ago and this is the only free entertainment that I am allowed to watch but as always keep shooting videos for us 🙏🙏🙏

HEY BROTHER! Omg, I love these podcast, i first found your video on YouTube about four years ago and I became obsessed 🤩! I did get in trouble for watching you video when I was supposed to be doing homework but it was honestly worth it. Your theories are so cool and you guys are so funny. Thanks for everything you do, love you guys ❤️❤️❤️! Also you two should read the Percy Jackson books, you don’t even need to make videos on them I just think you enjoy them. Ok byee!!

I found this podcast from YouTube, and I love being able to listen to all these series without staring at a screen all day.

I have been listening to this podcast for years now! I discovered you guys from your YouTube channel. I’ve loved your theory's since 2020! You guys are AMAZING. I still remember listening to your vids for the first time and I was so hooked. I listen to the POP as-well... 10/10 best podcast ever!!!

found this from the yt channel. Love the hp content

I just listen to this for the Harry Potter stuff. It's nice to listen to :D