I love their analysis and they have good insights that is different than what I hear other people saying about the show. The different perspectives are refreshing, especially about midge and Joel as parents. I LOVE that they make connections to Gilmore Girls! It’s my favorite show. I pick up on a lot of the connections but there are ones I have missed that they have pointed out. One star removed though because they don’t finish the season’s! I would love to hear their take on the finale.

Where are the podcasts for the last two episodes of the SERIES??

Please stick to the show we’re actually watching. You gave an explanation for why you can’t stop talking about GG, but it doesn’t hold water for me. Let this show stand on its own. I love MMM, but would need to be paid to watch GG. Yuck!

I love the Mrs. Maisel show and I think this podcast is really fun to listen to. I’ve heard other Maisel podcasts but they tend to just summarize the episodes. You guys actually pick at it and offer your opinions and theories. They almost always match my thinking. You guys have great chemistry and I enjoy the bantering! Plus you have great voices! I’d highly recommend this podcast!

I enjoy unpacking these episodes with Caroline and Paul. The episodes are so rich, I need the help. While I don’t always agree with their takes, I always walk away having learned something new. My experience as a fan is enhanced with this podcasts… thank you!

Oh my god - she talks about Gilmore Girls way too much. It’s pretty ridiculous. It’s SO annoying. Stop trying to bring that show into this one. I understand they have the same creator but they are their own separate shows and I am sick and tired of hearing about Gilmore Girls on a podcast about The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.

I really enjoyed listening to this podcast, but why were episodes 7 and 8 of the latest season never covered? Those were very important and you can’t just leave us hanging!

I love this podcast and I want to give it five stars but where in the heck is the last episode!!? It’s been driving me crazy!!!

Just discovered this podcast because I listen to another podclubhouse pod. Really love how in depth they get into the show! Caroline has a real talent for pointing out details in the show that I never thought about! Paul and Caroline make a great team-keep it up! Im listening❤️

I’m new to this podcast; just listened to your recent episode about season 4 episode 1. But you let me down. You guys start in the middle of the episode, you jump all around, and you seem to think Joel wrote a check for $50,000 (you think Midge, a new comic, earned the equivalent of half a million dollars on her first tour as an opening act? Y’all are just sloppy; in season 3, Midge and Susie clearly talk about how she’ll make $4500 and Susie gets $450 or something like that). I’m also not interested in your guesses about what the season will hold; if they happen, then that’ll spoil the season, right? Anyway, just figured I’d leave some feedback.