I love Conrad and Jeremiah bc I’m team belly, so I chose to be team all of them.

I enjoy it!

I love a long form podcast and Kara is so easy to listen to. I just enjoy hearing all the extra detail and analysis of character motivations. Thank you for creating more tsitp content it’s honestly getting me through my withdrawal!!

The best analysis and I am so glad someone has made a podcast to speak on what has been consuming my mind for weeks on end!! Kara is obviously Team Conrad, but if you truly watch and understand the show, how can you not be? With Kara’s analysis we really see how intricate all the details of the show are, and how all roads lead to Belly and Conrad being soulmates. I don’t understand how anyone could even be Team Jeremiah… but nonetheless, this podcast is filling in my little TSITP void while we wait for season 3 and I love everything part about it!<3

I really enjoy your breakdowns of the shows and you definitely make me think of details that hadn’t crossed my mind! I love the show by show breakdowns and everything you’ve put out afterwards (still catching up on those!) I wouldn’t consider myself team Jeremiah, but I do get a bit of a biased vibe towards Conrad. I wish you would be a bit more unbiased/generalized when you recap the shows. I’ll still listen regardless and think you’ve done a great job 🩵

As we wait for the writers/actors strikes continue, this podcast is exactly what my heart needs. Deep dives are always welcomed. Thank you for doing this and continue to give us what we need while we wait for Season 3 to be filmed. You are the best Kara!!

So sad to give a the summer I turned pretty podcast a bad review because I love the show and love talking about it, but this podcast really is hard to get through. I even listened to this with a friend of mine who is #teamconrad so that we could talk more about the show, and she was shocked by how they talk about Jeremiah. We couldn’t even make it through one episode. There are many times that it goes beyond just being bias and things that are said about Jeremiah are completely untrue, like that he is “evil” or a “terrible brother” who doesn’t care about anyone. I honestly don’t think we’re watching the same show if you truly believe that about him. Even if you aren’t team Jeremiah but you like Jeremiah as a character at all, you will not like listening to this podcast. I also think that it would be great to have a guest on who has some different opinions about the show rather than just seeing things from one very extreme side that I don’t think most of us are on.

As someone that’s a huge fan of the show myself, I’ve thoroughly enjoyed listening to Kara’s views on the episodes! I love that she goes into details about the soundtrack too and I’ve found that super informative. Can’t wait to finish listening and look forward to hearing more!

love this podcast and a in-depth analysis. after watching the show and tik toks I needed to consume more TSITP content because I needed to absorb and process this show… I am so Team Conrad but all my friends are team Jeremiah and didn’t see what I see. I am so glad you noticed all the details I did and also dive so much deeper than I thought… great work . what show/ book is next?

I found out about this podcast from seeing Kara’s breakdowns of TSITP on TikTok (which are also amazing!) but it’s really nice to engage w/ this content on another platform that allows for further inspection & analysis.

Kara is so insightful at analyzing this series, it will make you see it in a whole new light!

I hate to leave anything but a 5 star review but I’ve listened to 5 episodes and it keeps getting more painful. Kara is just SO #teamconrad that it’s hard for someone who is #teamjeremiah to actually find joy in this podcast which is the point of listening to a TSITP podcast. Kara does a GREAT job of recapping each episode and is so well spoken, but the fact that Conrad can do anything and she turns it into him being a great guy and then Jeremiah does something very small and he is “evil”. It would be amazing if Kara did the podcast with someone who could offer another point of view.

So insightful! Love that you’re team conrad!!

As someone who is unable to have a healthy relationship with a series, I’m happy this podcast exists. I live for deep dives & Kara goes into each episode and book detail perfectly. I look forward to more breakdowns of past seasons, future season, the books, all of it. 💖

I follow Kara on IG and was excited to learn she started this podcast. I love YA books and shows as well and it’s awesome to hear someone else analyze and break down each episode. So many Easter egg discoveries I didn’t notice the first time around. I just finished the season finale :’( but I can’t wait to hear the break down of this episode!

Really love the deep dive and thoughtful analysis. Listening on my commute and it really passes the time. Can’t wait to hear more! I just love this show so really enjoyed this!

This podcast is so fun and a great companion to watching the show. Kara’s attention to detail is impressive and she makes it feel like you’re talking to a friend about your favorite TV show!

Loved the deep dive into the storyline and foreshadowing as well. Picking apart pieces of the show I grazed over and now I can’t help but see! Love it!

If you’re like me and enjoy seeing and hearing what others have to say about the content you consume, this is perfect for you. Easy listen for any TSITP fan that goes surprisingly deeper into topics than you’d expect.